Reese’s Review of My Brother Sam is Dead

Newbery Honor Book
One of the 100 most challenged books list (bookspot.com)

Exposition:

At the beginning of the American Revolution, Sam Meeker walks in the door of the taproom wearing the uniform of the Patriots to greet his younger brother Tim and both his parents. His father is less than enthusiastic that Sam has joined the Minutemen and plans to fight against the "King".

Conflict:

 Though Sam has joined the Minutemen, his family believes he is foolish. Tim is somewhat torn between admiration for his brother and his upbringing. Sam steals his father's gun and runs away to fight. Tim doesn't know where his loyalty truly lies.

Rising Action:

Tim's parents are almost killed when Rebel forces demand the gun which Tim then attempts to steal back from his brother who is temporarily back. Meanwhile, Tim has been delivering letters which some think contain spy information. Tim's father is taken prisoner and later killed as he and Tim return from a trading journey. Sam serves three years of service, only to be accused of stealing cattle (partially because his parents are known Tory supporters).

Climax:

Tim begs General Putnam for clemency but is refused.

Falling Action:

Sam is executed at musket point by Continental soldiers as a lesson to all the soldiers. Tim watches, not screaming until they lift their muskets up to him.

Resolution:

Tim and his mother continue to own and work at the tavern in Redding after the war's end. The tavern is sold and they move. Tim builds a new tavern and branches out; eventually, Tim marries and has children.

Literary Elements:

The authors bring the characters to life through their use of rich dialogue. The reader' understanding of the historical time period is further expanded because of the believability of the plot and the style/language use throughout the novel.

Collier, J.L. & Collier, C. (1974). My brother Sam is Dead. New York: Scholastic.